CQ Roll Call June 19, 2013 | Register

It's Time to Eliminate the Payroll Tax

Ross Douthat: “Whatever its past political advantages, the payroll tax now imposes an unnecessary burden on a stagnating economy. In an era of mass unemployment, mediocre wage growth and weak mobility from the bottom of the income ladder, it makes no sense to finance our retirement system with a tax that falls directly on wages and hiring and imposes particular burdens on small business and the working class.”

“All of the components of a sensible Social Security reform — means-testing for wealthier beneficiaries, changing the way benefits adjust for inflation, a slow increase in the retirement age — become easier if the program is treated as normal safety-net spending rather than an untouchable entitlement with a dedicated funding stream.”

  • mingpicket

    a great first step to killing social security would be to move it away from being the current earned benefit that it is.

    • Wynstone

      Agreed. Without a dedicated funding mechanism, it is too easy to dismiss as “too expensive” and “wealth redistribution”.

  • JNo

    I don’t really get how you fund Social Security without it unless it’s privatized?

  • disqus_GVKlAv0ZT8

    SSI is the one thing that works. You pay into the system X amount of years, receive X amount of benefits based on what is paid into the system. Of course when you raid the trust and it looks like SSI is a line in the budget it seems expensive…. but Social Security itself is in SURPLUS!

    I will support raising the cap, raising the age, and lowering future benefits to push its solvency past ?2038? or whatever the date is. Only if we rebuild the SSI Trust.

    Now Medicare on the other hand……..ugh!

  • jeromekjerome

    SSI only needs three changes: eliminate the cap on contributions, means-test the benefits and establish an automatic mechanism to periodically change the benefits age in line with life expectancy.

Sign In

Forgot password?

Or

Subscribe

Receive daily coverage of the people, politics and personality of Capitol Hill.

Subscription | Free Trial

Logging you in. One moment, please...