CQ Roll Call May 22, 2013 | Register

It's Time to Talk About Guns

As the nation grapples with the heartbreaking news out of Connecticut, Ezra Klein calls for an end to the silence on gun control.

“If roads were collapsing all across the United States, killing dozens of drivers, we would surely see that as a moment to talk about what we could do to keep roads from collapsing. If terrorists were detonating bombs in port after port, you can be sure Congress would be working to upgrade the nation’s security measures. Only with gun violence do we respond to repeated tragedies by saying that mourning is acceptable but discussing how to prevent more tragedies is not. But that’s unacceptable.”

Marc Ambinder: “The answer to me is fairly obvious: Everyone who wants to have access to a gun can do so provided they register their weapon and get state-sanctioned training. The types of guns that people can carry on their persons ought to be limited to those made legitimately for self-defense. The gun show loophole should be closed; with the exception of family-to-family transactions or old weapons given as gifts, every sale or exchange of a weapon must be registered. The instant background check will be replaced for new gun owners with a state-approved training course that includes a more extensive background check.”

David Weigel notes that “the recent trend in gun laws has been toward expansion. Dramatically so.”

In President Obama’s tearful remarks on the shooting, he briefly noted that “we’re going to have to come together and take meaningful action to prevent more tragedies like this, regardless of the politics.”

  • DT wxrisk

    The shooter killed is father in New Jersey…. Travels to CT then kills his mother… Then killed 18 defenseless toddlers. I think it’s safe to say he is mentally ill.

    So was the person who shot the congressman Gaby Gifford….
    So was the Batman shooter…
    So was the columbine shooters.
    So was the Virginia Tech shooter.

    We seem to have absolutely no mental health system in this country whatsoever…. And that’s always going to cause big problems when they have access to firearms .

    • topjob66t

      7 hours later we know that he didn’t kill his father. He did kill his mother and took the car with guns and did some really horrific things.
      My wife, who is and aid in a school, came home and was in tears because she knows we cut out a lot of staff that are supposed to monitor mental health issues.
      I haven’t the heart to give her statistics on what universal healthcare provides. We here in the US have the biggest baggage of troubled people.
      I know there are sensible solutions and assault rifles and large clips must be banned.
      If Japan requires a mental health test to own an air rifle can’t we beef up the regulations a bit?

  • Anonymous

    Why is everyone tiptoeing around the elephant in the room here?

    Our federal constitution is wrong. The 2nd amendment language is far too broad. It needs to be changed.

    Let this be a lesson to people prone to nostalgia. The people who drafted our constitution were politicians. On top of that, many of them were the most repugnant, disgusting characters, like Thomas Jefferson for instance, who kidnapped and held for forced labor his own sister, then slept with her for years, while writing the most degenerate, delusional screeds about her and men and women like her in facile essays like those in Notes on the State of Virginia.

    Characters like this aren’t the ‘fathers’ of anything, let alone the minor deities so many are wont to make them. They were politicians, just as venal as ours today, and more. The sooner we realize that, the sooner we can get to work removing some of the detritus they codified into law.

    • Tom_P

      Because they are the idols of our national cult. Give people something to replace them with first.

      • Anonymous

        Yea. The last century and a half has produced several substitutes. But we could certainly do with more, I agree.

    • FreeStateLarry

      I think Thomas Jefferson was the ‘father’ of much more than we know…wink wink

    • topjob66t

      So you won’t give them much credit for framing a document that apposed a worse way of living? Interesting the way you wrote that.
      I’ll work with the Constitution and refrain from pointing out the early infallibilities of the Framers as they worked with what they had to form a better idea of governance. Might just be me.

      • Anonymous

        No need to distort my comment in order to perpetuate fetes of minor deity politicians.

        There’s clearly much about the federal constitution that’s very good. But the uncritical fawning and myth-making you and many others insist on shrouding that law and the politicians who drafted in largely serve to discourage to the point of forswearing rational and necessary amendments.

        As to opposing a worst way of living, there was enough deeply sick policy in the original to balance the many good provisions, so that it effectively mandated an unspeakably hellish way of living for many millions of Americans then, so much so that several wars had to waged and much blood shed to get around that all but immovable law.

  • Visible Mystery
  • Delphine

    What about the gajillion guns that are already out there? You know, the ones that “if guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have”? Are we going to have MPs go door-to-door conducting searches for them? Because personally I am fine with that, I have to say. I will offer them cookies and heartfelt thanks for all they do.

  • Richard Fisher

    The far right (NRA in this case) owns the political process. Military commanding officers and (I think) psychiatrists are not even allowed to ask soldiers about guns they own personally. Amazing!

    I would point out that none of the reasonable gun control ideas would have prevented this tragedy. Even Ambinder suggested that guns should be allowed to pass down through families without the same controls as gun purchases.

    I believe this problem has to be dealt with at both ends: 1, good, reasonable gun laws that help protect society without being an undue restriction on responsible, educated gun owners, and 2, better mental health services, including counseling for their families about just these type of concerns. It seems that we as a society. Are so focused on the individual that we forget that certain things, such as mental health services, are necessary for the larger, societal good.

Sign In

Forgot password?

Or

Subscribe

Receive daily coverage of the people, politics and personality of Capitol Hill.

Subscription | Free Trial

Logging you in. One moment, please...