CQ Roll Call June 19, 2013 | Register

Virginia Looks at Replacing Gas Tax

“Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell (R) has unveiled a transportation funding plan that calls for eliminating the tax on gasoline purchases in his state… To replace it, McDonnell is calling for a 0.8 percent increase in Virginia’s state sales tax to generate revenue that would be dedicated to transportation,” The Hill reports.

“Transportation advocates at both the federal and state levels have argued for a new funding mechanism for road and transit construction as cars have become more energy efficient.”

Matthew Yglesias argues that this is “the most straightforwardly terrible policy I’ve heard in a while.”

“If anything, it makes the tax structure even more regressive since the carless minority in the United States is disproportionately composed of poor people. The nice thing about a gas tax is that…it does have environmental and highway congestion benefits. Higher retail sales taxes have all the annoyance but none of the benefits.”

  • http://mulderc.blogspot.com/ Cameron Mulder

    Wow, that is an impressively stupid idea.

  • Forrest

    Sounds like a typical Republican policy to me.

  • rhodent

    If they’re going to replace the gas tax, then it should be either be absorbed by the income tax or replaced with some other tax based on actual road usage (perhaps an annual fee based on your odometer reading from year to year). But really, if the gas tax isn’t bringing in enough money, it seems to me the obvious solution is to raise the gas tax. Call me biased, but I think I deserve a break for my decision to buy a car that gets 41 mpg instead of one that only gets in the ballpark of 20 mpg.

  • Mark_in_VA

    Good on-ya, T-Vag Bob. And if that doesn’t generate enough revenue, maybe you can sell the children of the poor into indentured servitude. That may be so successful you can tack on a top-bracket rate reduction, ta’ boot!

Sign In

Forgot password?

Or

Subscribe

Receive daily coverage of the people, politics and personality of Capitol Hill.

Subscription | Free Trial

Logging you in. One moment, please...